Has Halo Reached the End of the Ring?

There comes a clip successful each long-running franchise’s beingness wherever a question begins to fester successful fans and non-fans’ minds: should this still beryllium going? Look astatine Sonic, the MCU, DCEU, and countless others for examples. At a definite point, usually followed by a fig of high-profile duds, the treatment keeps increasing and increasing until… well, until you’re Halo, I guess.

Bungie’s Halo 2 released for the archetypal Xbox November 9, 2004. A decennary later, connected November 11, 2014, 343 Industries enactment retired Halo: The Master Chief Collection, a remaster of the then-four mainline entries that contained a remake of the 2nd crippled arsenic its main selling point. If Halo 3 was the archetypal blockbuster crippled arsenic we cognize it today, a batch of that is acknowledgment to the legwork done by its predecessor. In what’s commonplace nowadays, Microsoft promoted the crippled arsenic a large taste lawsuit you conscionable had to beryllium a portion of. Then-executive Peter Moore famously revealed the game’s merchandise with a tattoo connected his limb astatine E3 2004 and the alternate world crippled I Love Bees targeted the net crowd, portion trailers played successful movie theaters (the archetypal crippled to bash so). Even stone bands similar Breaking Benjamin and Hoobastank contributing “inspired-by” songs to the game’s soundtrack were portion of a concentrated effort to deed non-players implicit the caput that this was a crippled worthy paying attraction to.

And it was worth paying attraction to: wrong the archetypal time of its release, Halo 2 sold 2.4 cardinal copies and made $125 cardinal successful revenue, becoming the biggest amusement merchandise successful history. Critics called it a large sequel successful astir each way, and its multiplayer was the most-played rubric connected Xbox Live for astir 2 full years until the original Gears of War launched connected the Xbox 360. A steadfast proviso of post-launch DLC and the 360 being backwards compatible kept it going for a loooooooong time, to the constituent that Microsoft repeatedly pushed backmost the day it was going to unopen down its servers. Master Chief Collection, while not without its faults, did its main occupation successful bringing Halo 2 to a caller console generation—and ensured connected a playability level that Halo wouldn’t beryllium forgotten.

Since 343 took afloat stewardship of the series, things haven’t wholly gone to plan. In 2015, Halo 5: Guardians saw a mixed response—much of it directed toward its run and narrative—that yet resulted successful 2021’s Halo Infinite. That crippled had a batch to transportation connected its back; on with celebrating the franchise’s 20th anniversary, it had a unsmooth archetypal showing and a reportedly troubled improvement that aboriginal resulted successful respective cardinal squad members leaving 343. It besides had to cleanable up Guardians’ communicative threads and hole the franchise for its adjacent saga, and it didn’t truly bash that. Hearts and minds were won with Infinite’s free-to-play multiplayer, but immoderate archetypal ambitions the workplace had for Infinite were considerably scaled back. Combined with a middling TV amusement and a diminished expanded universe, it’s grown wide successful the past fewer years that Halo is disarray. Some of it’s self-inflicted, immoderate whitethorn stem from Microsoft’s ain uncertainty astir what it wants from (or to do) with Xbox overall, but it’s been hard to disregard the elephant successful the room.

In October, 343 changed its sanction to Halo Studios and revealed respective caller Halo game projects were being made with Epic Games’ Unreal Engine. Its Unreal-made concepts all locomotion the Spartan locomotion and look the part, but they besides amusement however constricted the series’ ocular playbook has go now. (Guardians tried to premix things up, but the game’s efforts to turn Halo weren’t each met positively.) Halo’s multiplayer is inactive aces and the astir consistently bully happening astir the series; astir of its ongoing issues situation its narrative. In immoderate ways, Halo 2 is wherever this each started, fixed however arguable its run ended up being with the astonishment uncover of 2 protagonists—players besides instrumentality connected the relation of the Arbiter, a disgraced Covenant warrior tasked with hunting down dissenters voiced by Keith “The Man” David—and arguable cliffhanger ending.

© Bungie/Xbox

But times person changed, and the franchise scenery is truthful antithetic that cliffhangers consciousness much unsafe than ever. These days, a bid could easy chopped disconnected whatever’s deemed expendable if it’s not an instantly beloved deed alternatively of giving it clip to turn into itself. This has been the Halo’s biggest contented aft Bungie moved connected to different ventures, and it’s enactment the series’ single-player outings successful a authorities of arrested development. It’s conscionable not healthy for a bid that’s been pulled astir successful truthful galore directions truthful galore times to effort and support going, particularly 1 that continuously talks a large crippled and past stumbles erstwhile it comes to communicative payoff. Infinite wasn’t atrocious by immoderate means, but it whitethorn person burned up immoderate leftover goodwill and nostalgia from the archetypal games that the bid had.

None of this is to accidental that Microsoft conscionable should melee Halo in the backmost of the caput and hide it; Dragon Age: The Veilguard has shown that any bid tin marque a comeback. Triple-A games are being afforded little clip these days to marque a genuine lawsuit for themselves pre and post-launch, and it would suck for Halo to beryllium permanently declared MIA. But if Xbox is superior astir keeping the franchise astir and not wholly ditching it for Call of Duty, the bid mightiness request to instrumentality immoderate due clip disconnected truthful Halo Studios tin find some what it wants Halo to beryllium and however to champion get there.

Want much io9 news? Check retired erstwhile to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s adjacent for the DC Universe connected movie and TV, and everything you request to cognize astir the aboriginal of Doctor Who.