Kamala Harris’s Patriotic Spin on Climate Action

This communicative was primitively published by Grist. Sign up for Grist’s weekly newsletter here.

“Freedom” is often a Republican talking point, but Vice President Kamala Harris is trying to reclaim the conception for Democrats arsenic portion of her run for the presidency. In a code astatine the Democratic National Convention past month, she declared that “fundamental freedoms” were astatine involvement successful the November election, including “the state to respire cleanable aerial and portion cleanable h2o and unrecorded escaped from the contamination that fuels the clime crisis.”

A caller survey suggests Harris mightiness beryllium onto thing if she’s trying to person voters torn betwixt her and erstwhile President Donald Trump. Researchers astatine New York University recovered that framing clime enactment arsenic patriotic and arsenic indispensable to sphere the American “way of life” tin summation enactment for clime enactment among radical crossed the governmental spectrum successful the United States.

“It’s encouraging to spot politicians adopting this benignant of language,” said Katherine Mason, a co-author of the survey and a science researcher astatine New York University. Based connected the study’s results, she said that this rhetoric “may span governmental divides astir clime change.”

Some 70 percent of Americans already enactment the authorities taking enactment to code clime change, including astir younger Republicans, according to a canvass from CBS News earlier this year. Experts person agelong suggested that appealing to Americans’ consciousness of patriotism could activate them.

The framing has taken signifier nether President Joe Biden’s administration, which has pushed for policies to manufacture electrical vehicles and chargers domestically “so that the large American roadworthy travel tin beryllium electrified.” Harris underscored this attack to clime and vigor in Tuesday’s statesmanlike debate with Trump, emphasizing efforts to trade “American-made” EVs and turning a question astir fracking into a telephone for little reliance connected “foreign oil.”

Mason’s new study, published successful the diary Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, is the largest to day connected the effects of patriotic connection astir clime change, with astir 60,000 participants crossed 63 countries. Americans work a connection declaring that being pro-environment would assistance “keep the United States arsenic it should be,” arguing that it was “patriotic to conserve the country’s earthy resources.”

The substance was illustrated by photos of the American emblem blowing successful the wind, picturesque nationalist parks, and climate-related impacts, specified arsenic a flooded Houston aft Hurricane Harvey and a Golden Gate Bridge shrouded successful an orangish haze of wildfire smoke. Reading it accrued people’s level of content successful clime change, their willingness to stock accusation astir clime alteration connected societal media, and their enactment for policies to support the environment, specified arsenic raising c taxes and expanding nationalist transit.

The researchers wanted to trial a intelligence mentation that radical often support the presumption quo, adjacent if it’s flawed, due to the fact that they privation stability, not uncertainty and conflict. “This mindset presents a large obstruction erstwhile it comes to tackling large problems similar clime change, arsenic it leads radical to downplay the occupation and defy indispensable changes to support the environment,” Mason said.

For decades, biology advocates person called connected radical to marque sacrifices for the greater bully — to motorcycle alternatively of drive, devour much vegetables alternatively of meat, and crook down the thermostat successful the winter. Asking radical to springiness up things tin pb to backlash, said Emma Frances Bloomfield, a connection prof astatine the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. The framing successful the survey flips that connected its head, she said. “It’s not asking radical to sacrifice oregon marque extremist changes, but successful fact, doing things for the situation volition forestall the extremist alteration of the biology catastrophe.”

Bloomfield, who has studied however to find communal crushed with conservatives connected clime change, wasn’t amazed the survey recovered that appealing to patriotism worked successful the United States. In different countries, however, the results were little wide — the patriotic connection saw immoderate affirmative effects successful Brazil, France, and Israel, but backfired successful different countries, including Germany, Belgium, and Russia.

Bloomfield urged caution successful deploying this strategy successful the existent world, since it could travel crossed arsenic trying to manipulate conservatives by pandering to them. “Patriotism oregon immoderate benignant of framing message, I think, tin decidedly backfire if it’s not seen arsenic an authentic transportation connected values,” she said.

Talking astir a planetary biology occupation successful an overly patriotic, competitory mode could beryllium different pitfall. Earlier this year, a survey successful the diary Environmental Communication recovered that a “green nationalist” framing — which pits countries against 1 different successful presumption of biology advancement — reduced people’s enactment for policies to bounds greenhouse state emissions. Natalia Bogado, the writer of that survey and a science researcher successful Germany, said that the caller survey successful PNAS makes “no notation to the cardinal characteristics of nationalism, but lone concisely mentions a patriotic duty,” which mightiness partially explicate the antithetic results.

If executed smartly, though, appealing to determination loyalty tin pb to enactment for biology causes. Take the “Don’t Mess With Texas” campaign, started successful the precocious 1980s to trim litter on the state’s highways. Its people was the young men casually chucking brew cans retired their motortruck windows, believing littering was a “God-given right.” Instead of challenging their identity, the run channeled their Texas pride, with stunning results: Litter connected the roads plunged 72 percent successful conscionable 4 years. Today, the operation has go synonymous with Texas swagger — truthful overmuch truthful that galore person forgotten it was initially an anti-litter message.

This nonfiction primitively appeared successful Grist astatine https://grist.org/language/kamala-harris-climate-change-freedom-patriotism-study/. Grist is simply a nonprofit, autarkic media enactment dedicated to telling stories of clime solutions and a conscionable future. Learn much astatine Grist.org