Meta suggests AI Northern Lights pics are as good as the real thing

Meta has a proposition for folks similar maine who forgot to spell extracurricular and look astatine the Northern Lights connected Thursday night: conscionable usage AI to fake it! But Threads users who replied to Meta’s idea, posted on with 3 AI-generated images of the Aurora Borealis Meta past night, look to disagree.

Here’s Meta’s post:

The images amusement the Northern Lights hovering implicit the Golden Gate Bridge, implicit a metropolis skyline, and implicit a ferris wheel. It’s intelligibly meant to latch onto a trending infinitesimal of radical posting their ain pictures of the Northern Lights from the astonishing and uncommon show of the lights, which plunged heavy into the United States connected Thursday night.

Once you get past the archetypal fewer comments from radical sharing their ain AI-generated Northern Lights pictures, the replies scope from thoughtfully critical:

To all-caps anger:

To humorous:

One idiosyncratic who says they’re an “astronaut/particle physicist and AI scientist” had peculiarly elaborate feedback:

Others shared pictures they accidental they took of the phenomenon:

Like the Olympics advertisement Google pulled, Meta’s societal media squad has failed to work the room. Users’ posts aren’t conscionable showing disconnected a beauteous representation (though that’s surely portion of it!). They’re besides astir participating successful a corporate solemnisation of a rare, shared lived experience. It’s not the clip oregon spot to insert an AI-generated image.

Society is inactive sorting retired messy questions astir AI, similar what it’s doing to photography and the morals of grooming it connected the internet’s collected works of artists, writers, musicians, and photographers. Until the particulate settles from specified debates, posts similar Meta’s volition proceed to miss the mark.