Rings of Power Is Smashing a Pick Axe Into Its Slowly Formed Cracks

Rings of Power has always, by and large, been a slow-paced show. At slightest intentionally truthful immoderate of the time, wanting you to luxuriate successful the dollar walk of the afloat equipped and operational occurrence powerfulness of a Jeff Bezos-backed streaming media empire with its lavish visuals and affluent sets. Otherwise, it’s conscionable the condition of the show’s set-up; with truthful galore abstracted plotlines each dispersed crossed Middle-earth, it takes clip to drawback up with each. That means erstwhile the amusement breaks that pace, it’s notable. And sometimes it works—a abbreviated crisp shock that reminds you what’s truly astatine stake. And sometimes… it’s conscionable benignant of a weird reminder astir the precise quality of this full adaptive endeavor.

After past week caught america up connected the Elven, Harfoot, and Southlands storylines (turns out, everyone’s beauteous miserable), this week “Halls of Stone” catches america up with Rings of Power‘s remaining spinning plates successful Eregion, Khazad-dûm, and Númenor. Turns out, everyone’s inactive beauteous miserable!

But if past week’s occurrence was a dilatory pain to wallow successful that misery—as evil rises up done Middle-earth’s precise flora and fauna—this week’s is 1 of a much contiguous action: things are abruptly going precise wrong, precise quickly, and nary 1 tin halt the wheels that either Sauron oregon the wide rot successful the aerial person begun to turn. At slightest successful 1 of our storylines, down with the dwarves, things commencement out good successful comparative comparison. After seeing his underground realm thrust into full acheronian by groundquakes in the premiere, King Durin embraces Celebrimbor’s acquisition of 7 rings for him and his chap Dwarf-Lords, and astir instantly puts it to enactment (and Disa retired of her song-divining job, it seems) locating the precise locations his lad and chap miners request to carve retired to reconstruct airy to Khazad-dûm again. Yay!

No. Not yay. In fact, the nonstop other of yay. Just arsenic rapidly arsenic we spot airy travel to Khazad-dûm again, we instantly commencement to spot Durin ensorcelled by his ring. It’s each precise Lord of the Rings-y, due to the fact that the amusement knows that’s benignant of precisely what you want: you cognize these rings are bad, adjacent if the characters don’t, truthful you privation to spot their countenance fall, you privation to spot them grasp and panic erstwhile they can’t find their precious jewelery, you privation to spot them go obsessive, and drawback astatine people, and crook inward. That is what you get, and it is decidedly disturbing to ticker unfold—especially with the underlying calamity that Durin the younger and his begetter had lone conscionable begun to repair their fractured narration aft the events of play one. His large fearfulness for his father’s abrupt crook successful disposition brings each these analyzable emotions to the surface, and Owain Arthur is impeccable arsenic a lad watching his begetter gaffe distant close successful beforehand of him.

But the crook is so fast—King Durin puts connected the ring, instantly goes light-shaft-sensing, and conscionable arsenic instantly starts getting his champion Bilbo-in-Fellowship content going—that portion an uptick successful immediate dire consequences is simply a footwear up the rear Rings of Power needed to get this play into precocious gear, determination is this inescapable feeling of suddenness that doesn’t beryllium right. There’s nary existent clip to beryllium with Durin’s descent, due to the fact that helium has to commencement atrocious the 2nd helium sees a ring, get worse, and past the occupation has to expound sevenfold erstwhile helium starts readying to delve deeper (greedily, even, due to the fact that of people we get a outcry retired to that celebrated Tolkien crook of phrase) into Khazad-dûm’s depths and nonstop the remaining rings retired to the different six Dwarf-Lords. There’s nary clip for immoderate benignant of motivation quandary oregon statement implicit their use; Rings of Power gets close to the constituent that astir of its assemblage knows, but successful the process, does a disservice to the characters on the way.

It’s a akin lawsuit successful some of the episode’s different plotlines. Let’s commencement with the astir ring-adjacent 1 successful Eregion, wherever each is rapidly not becoming good for besties Annatar and Celebrimbor successful the Forge. No sooner than the smiths and the Dwarves are celebrating renewed relationships with the instauration of the Doors of Durin (yes, the “speak ‘Friend’ and enter” ones) are Annatar and Celebrimbor astatine each other’s throats implicit the former’s plans to make 9 much rings, this clip for the leaders of humanity. There’s astatine slightest immoderate absorbing follow-up to uglier parts of Celebrimbor’s quality present to marque Sauron’s manipulation of him descend its hooks in: adjacent erstwhile he’s meant to beryllium celebrating confederation with the Dwarves, he’s making casually racist jokes astir their thirst for gems close successful beforehand of them, and erstwhile Annatar offers up the imaginable to trade 1 last acceptable of rings of power, Celebrimbor haughtily dismisses humanity excessively anemic and easy swayed to beryllium worthy of his ability. Celebrimbor’s downfall is not rather arsenic crisp arsenic King Durin’s, due to the fact that we already get to spot the elements of his quality that Sauron plies, but adjacent then, there’s a akin haste successful the Eregion crippled present that ironically weakens the stakes astatine play.

If radical tin instantly archer something’s incorrect with the rings, necessitating Annatar going a spot gaslight gatekeep girlboss (and adjacent Galadriel, erstwhile helium compares young forgesmith Mirdania to Halbrand’s erstwhile potential-paramour, arsenic helium wraps her astir his fingers) to effort and divided the smiths distant from their progressively distressed leader, it makes Sauron’s maestro plans consciousness a small little calculated and a small much slapdash. Even if the elements are determination for him to exploit successful characters similar Celebrimbor, that they statesman to interruption truthful instantly feels little similar masterful manipulation and much similar the dictation of the script. We know these Rings are bad, the amusement does too, we each cognize however this has to go—so portion we’re getting there, we’re getting determination successful a mode that feels a small excessively breakneck, and successful a mode that feels similar excessively abrupt a pivot from the slower gait of the season’s archetypal half. The twist present doesn’t consciousness similar a shock, similar Mount Doom’s detonation did successful play one, but flipping from 1 utmost to another.

It’s adjacent weirder successful the Númenor plot, due to the fact that adjacent determination they don’t truly person the excuse of Literally Evil Magic Rings to marque everyone abruptly determine to up their turbo-asshole levels. Pharazôn was conscionable made king implicit Míriel (that eagle mandate truly went a agelong way), but he’s already becoming a despot, casting retired the seaguard who were connected Míriel’s expedition, and sending his sniveling lad Kemen to ace down connected memorial services for the Númenoreans mislaid successful conflict for the Southlands. We’ve known the doomed aboriginal of the land nation arsenic portion of the substance for a while, astatine least, done Míriel’s visions successful the palantir—the precise happening that mislaid her her support—but again, nary of this feels peculiarly good built up, and similar things person to spell from 0 to 50 due to the fact that we haven’t watched idiosyncratic get stabbed lately (RIP to Valandil, conscionable to marque Elendil’s misery adjacent much palpable), and the amusement abruptly remembered that the assemblage truly likes it erstwhile things commencement happening.

The worldly connected Númenor feels a spot much of a agelong crippled than Sauron’s speedrun of his Eregion epoch (his Era-gion?), due to the fact that each this volition astatine slightest wage disconnected down the enactment erstwhile Sauron makes his mode implicit determination and begins his manipulations anew, but successful the moment, the escalation feels terrible little due to the fact that of immoderate peculiar hostility driving it—Pharazôn got what helium wanted, Míriel is seemingly astatine slightest accepting that she present has to play a agelong crippled to debar the aboriginal shown to her successful the palantir, Elendil inactive has a agelong mode to spell earlier helium becomes the aboriginal king of Númenor’s survivors—and much similar an escalation to lucifer the vibe displacement successful the remainder of Rings of Power‘s storylines.

Part of this, of course, is because Rings of Power has (rightfully even) chosen to condense what was hundreds and thousands of years successful Tolkien’s envisioning of the Second Age down to what is, ultimately, the lifespan of your mean Númenorean. When characters similar Elendil and Isildur are already successful the show, you by that quality have to laic retired the roadworthy for them to beryllium marching to the basal of Mount Doom by the clip Rings of Power is nearing its end. Master plans that instrumentality centuries, corruption that lingers and festers, it can’t brew implicit an extended play of time, the interaction has to beryllium immediate. I’m not saying that the amusement needed to amusement the transition of eons for this to person immoderate impact—it’s dilatory enough, astatine its worst—but it’s hard to consciousness similar the stakes present are truly each that dire if everything goes atrocious astatine the driblet of a chapeau oregon the top magical artifacts Middle-earth has ever seen are made successful what feels similar hours and days, alternatively than with peculiar effort.

That’s yet the occupation the bid faces arsenic it begins barreling towards the decision we cognize is coming this season. This occurrence adjacent ends with a tease of that, arsenic Elrond dashes backmost to Lindon to find that it’s excessively precocious to redirect Gil-Galad’s forces from Mordor to Eregion, and the captured Galadriel finds herself face-to-face with Adar (and his connection of a tenuous alliance) arsenic they basal connected the outer rims of the Elven kingdom, acceptable for the warfare to genuinely begin. If it can’t find a middle-ground to really make its characters, the interaction of the spectacle to travel is going to beryllium blunted, due to the fact that we’re waxing and waning betwixt excessively small happening and excessively overmuch each of a sudden. To get different Tolkienism, conscionable arsenic this occurrence did, it’s the proverbial food scraped implicit excessively overmuch bread: there’s moments present of thing satisfying to chew on, but they’re formed speech excessively quickly, excessively overmuch feast aft truthful overmuch famine, that you don’t truly get clip to swallow.

Want much io9 news? Check retired erstwhile to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s adjacent for the DC Universe connected movie and TV, and everything you request to cognize astir the aboriginal of Doctor Who.