Why Has Spider-Man Become Such a Movie Mess?

All told, Spider-Man is 1 of the weirdest high-profile superheroes. Peter Parker volition ever beryllium famous, and that means thing helium ends up headlining volition conscionable yet person an unusual aura astir it. Look nary further than his ain movies: aft Sam Raimi’s trilogy, Sony didn’t support the due clasp it had connected the franchise, yet resulting successful a shared custody deal with the quality which brought him to the Marvel Cinematic Universe via Tom Holland.

Holland’s Peter Parker made his debut successful Captain America: Civil War, and has yet divided his MCU clip arsenic a impermanent prima and three-time headliner. Of the existent trilogy, the sophomore effort of Spider-Man: Far From Home, which released connected July 2, 2019, came with baggage greater than 2017’s Homecoming. Coming conscionable implicit 2 months aft Avengers: Endgame, the movie got close to the constituent and positioned Peter arsenic a imaginable MCU anchor present that astir of the Avengers (and Robert Downey Jr.’s Tony Stark successful particular) either retired oregon died. Adding onto that is that portion Endgame brought the Infinity Saga to a close, Far From Home was the existent Phase Three capper alternatively than being the commencement for Phase Four, which held a throughline of young and caller characters stepping up to the forefront.

Image: Sony Pictures/Marvel

In the aforesaid mode Homecoming was astir Spider-Man being acceptable to bent with the large leagues, Far From Home asked if Peter (and by hold Holland) had what it takes to beryllium a caller large player. The reply is... benignant of complicated; Far From Home is a mostly good movie, but it truly highlighted the weird country Sony and Marvel enactment themselves in. Holland brings 110% to Peter’s youthful vigor and physicality, but the Home trilogy is much funny successful him arsenic a vas for enactment than arsenic a character. If Andrew Garfield’s Peter from the Amazing films was excessively handsome and modern, this instrumentality connected Peter lacks the borderline oregon bureau seen successful different versions, live-action oregon otherwise. It’s a weird thing, to spot however overmuch lacking successful interiority this 1 is.

Let it not beryllium said Far From Home didn’t present immoderate goods, though. It made $1.132 billion, becoming the archetypal Spider-flick to transverse that threshold and Sony’s past highest-grossing movie ever. But the movie couldn’t bask successful that glory for excessively long: the pursuing month, Marvel said it’d nary longer produce Spider-Man films, perchance putting Peter backmost successful Sony’s hands. Money was the basal of the dispute, with Sony reportedly assured capable successful its ain Spidey-related plans it was consenting to conscionable fto that concern fizzle out. Despite the occurrence of some Venom and Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse in 2018, nary 1 was consenting to hold and spot if Sony had the juice; fans called connected Marvel Studios to prevention Spider-Man (and possibly adjacent used bots to bash it), and adjacent Holland and Kevin Feige openly advocated for a renewed partnership.

What makes Spider-Man is truthful absorbing arsenic a movie spot is however each live-action mentation has been incapable to flight firm interference. While Spider-Man 3 and Amazing Spider-Man 2 had that conflict presented straight connected the screen, Far From Home refreshingly had its firm clash spell connected aft the fact. It’s 1 of the archetypal instances successful caller representation wherever the wide nationalist was made alert of however studios operate, and it doesn’t bent implicit the movie arsenic overmuch arsenic the Disney/Fox merger hung implicit Dark Phoenix and New Mutants or Legendary’s licensing woody with Toho does its MonsterVerse movies. Can aboriginal Spidey films debar this weirdness? That’s hard to find since Sony precise intelligibly wants to beverage the Spider-Man marque for arsenic overmuch arsenic it’s worthy and Marvel Studios to dainty this mentation arsenic a walking flex it tin trot retired whenever Sony gets too large for its webs.

Image: Sony Pictures/Marvel

Ultimately, the 2 corporations struck a new deal, redeeming Holland from getting tangled successful immoderate the hellhole Sony’s doing with the likes of Madame Web and Morbius. Even so, it’s anyone’s conjecture arsenic to what’s next. Since the play aft Spider-Man: No Way Home lit the satellite connected occurrence successful 2021, it’s been a large question people for if Holland volition suit up a fourth time. No Way Home gave Holland a wide ending to spell retired on, on with a jumping disconnected constituent for a new, hypothetically smaller bid of films. No uncertainty Sony wants to support him connected call, but he’s not getting immoderate younger, and the workplace has besides been unfastened astir getting idiosyncratic to tag successful arsenic Miles Morales erstwhile Spider-Man 4 is retired the door.  

Given however fashionable helium is, Spider-Man is often asked to bounce betwixt mid-size adventures successful New York and larger globe (or universe)-trotting epics alongside the Avengers, X-Men, and whoever else. Typically, helium and different Spider-characters similar Miles, Venom, and Gwen tin straddle this enactment reasonably well, but it truly shows erstwhile the equilibrium is off, usually erstwhile it leans toward the epic. In MCU Spidey’s case, this is the Home trilogy’s top fault: he’s excessively tiny for the bigness of these films. Like Garfield’s Peter earlier him, Holland’s incarnation is caught up betwixt antithetic masters and agendas. If we really are going to spot this Peter again successful a 4th movie, hopefully Marvel and Sony springiness him a accidental to conscionable bash his ain happening without lording implicit him.

Want much io9 news? Check retired erstwhile to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s adjacent for the DC Universe connected movie and TV, and everything you request to cognize astir the aboriginal of Doctor Who.